The difference between physics and mathematics writing

Being a mathematician, I am having difficulty getting my fluid-dynamics papers accepted for publication.   So I have come to the realization that mathematics and physics papers are vastly different.
The methodology in a mathematics paper is at least as important as the result; there are cases where a shorter proof generates almost as much excitement as the original.
It appears that for physicists, the result is paramount and the methodology is mainly for vetting the results.  To develop an elegant theory which provides results which are already known is of no interest; there must be some lack or deficiency in a known result for the physicist to read past the abstract.  And that lack or deficiency must be stated up front; one of my papers was rejected because it didn't tell a story.
Mathematicians tend to read a paper from start to finish and are delighted by footnotes with unexpected connections to other fields.  The Journal of Fluid Mechanics nearly forbids footnotes in their instructions for authors.
There are variations among physics journals as well.  For journals with an engineering bent, stating that a coefficient of 0.450 is actually sqrt(2)/pi is probably best left out.

Real-time interactive mathematical marbling

Blake Jones has done some righteous coding, creating a GPU implementation of the Oseen flow in paint marbling algorithm which executes so fast that it renders the marbling from arbitrary stylus movements interactively in real time!  The first video on his Turing clouds webpage shows the system in action.

Mathematical Marbling How-To

http://people.csail.mit.edu/jaffer/Marbling/How-To

Paint marbling is a process of dropping colored paints onto a liquid bath and raking (combing) them to create intricate designs.  Based on my mathematical theory of marbling, Jürgen Gilg, Manuel Luque, and I have created the pst-marble software to enable anyone with an internet browser to create their own digital marbled designs. 
Pst-marble (and documentation) is a CTAN package for the LaTeX document system.  If you have LaTeX and CTAN installed on your computing device, then you can create marblings locally.  https://www.latex-project.org/get/ has the downloads and instructions for installing LaTeX and CTAN on GNU/Linux, MacOS, and Windows.
For those with a web-browser, it is easy to create marblings online. Papeeria.com provides an online LaTeX workbench with free and paid accounts.  The marbling example files will render in less than one minute; so a free account is sufficient for exploring.  If you create more complicated designs, you can upgrade to a paid Papeeria account or install LaTeX and CTAN on a (larger) computing device.

• Download pst-marble-v1.4.zip (15 kB) onto your computing device.
• Go to http://Papeeria.com and create a free account for yourself and a "project" with whatever name you like.
• From the top left pull-down select Upload Project, then Choose files and select pst-marble-v1.4.zip which you just downloaded.  Then click Open.
• In the Project tab you should then see a list of filenames. The files with capitalized first letter and ending with .tex are the marbling example files.
• Click on Nonpareil.tex and you will see lines of text which are a small marbling program.  Find the Papeeria Compile pull down and click on Nonpareil.tex.  In less than 30 seconds a colorful design will appear in the PDF tab (you may need to install a PDF viewer on your device).

Low resolution rendering of Nonpareil.tex

Returning to the Nonpareil.tex code: After the \psMarble line there are several sections bounded by curly braces { and }. The colors= section accepts RGB colors in three formats.

[0.906 0.8 0.608]

Red, green, and blue color components between 0 and 1 in square brackets.

[231 204 155]

Red, green, and blue color components between 0 and 255 in square brackets.

(e7cc9b)

Red, green, and blue (RRGGBB) hexadecimal color components between 00 and fF in parentheses.

The percent symbol % is the comment character in .tex files.  Text to the right of % is ignored to the end-of-line.  Try commenting out some color lines, then click on Papeeria's Compile button; you should see fewer colors in the resulting marbling PDF.
The actions= section in Nonpareil.tex specifies the marbling design through a sequence of numbers (arguments) and commands separated by whitespace.  The system is a bit unusual in that the command is to the right of its arguments.  The leftmost two arguments to most of the commands are the x and y coordinates of the center of the marbling action.  0 0 for the first two arguments specifies the center of the design.  The visible x and y for a square image are from -500 to +500; but the virtual tank is infinite in size. 
Comment out four lines of the actions= section so that it looks like this; then Compile:

      0 0 48 colors 25 concentric-rings
%      90  [-150 450] 100 750 31 rake
%      -90 [-150 450] 100 750 31 rake
%      180 [ 25 50 0 tines ] 30 200 31 rake
%      0 230 shift

You should now see concentric colored rings in the PDF viewer. These are produced by concentric-rings command:

x y R_i [rgb ...] n concentric-rings

Places n rings in color sequence [rgb ...] centered at location x,y, each ring having thickness R_i.

These 25 rings are centered in the PDF and have a value of 48 for thickness. The colors argument refers to the color sequence from the colors= section. It can be replaced by a literal color sequence; for instance:
0 0 48 [(c28847) [231 204 155] [0.635 0.008 0.094]] 25 concentric-rings Next, uncomment the first two rake lines so that the actions= section looks like this; then Compile:

      0 0 48 colors 25 concentric-rings
      90  [-150 450] 100 750 31 rake
      -90 [-150 450] 100 750 31 rake
%      180 [ 25 50 0 tines ] 30 200 31 rake
%      0 230 shift

θ [R ...] V S D rake

Pulls tines of diameter D at θ degrees clockwise from the positive y-axis through the virtual tank at velocity V, moving fluid on the tine path a distance S.  The tine paths are spaced [R ...] from the tank center at their nearest points.

"90 [-150 450] 100 750 31 rake" rakes two tines from left to right.
"-90 [-150 450] 100 750 31 rake" rakes two tines from right to left. The tine tracks are distinct from the previous two because they are rotated 180 degrees. It is important to offset the tines so that rakes in opposite direction do not cancel each other out. You can see this cancellation by changing [-150 450] to [-300 300] in both lines.
Raking left and right increases the number of color bands. The next step will rake downward with 25 tines. While we could specify their positions as 25 numbers between brackets, pst-marble offers a utility for generating evenly spaced tines:

[n S Ω tines]

The tines command and its arguments are replaced by a sequence of n numbers. The difference between adjacent numbers is S and the center number is Ω when n is odd and S/2−Ω when n is even.

[2 600 -150 tines] is equivalent to [-150 450]. For the 25 tine rake, uncomment the rake line in actions= so that it looks like this; then Compile:

    0 0 48 colors 25 concentric-rings
    90  [-150 450] 100 750 31 rake
    -90 [-150 450] 100 750 31 rake
    180 [ 25 50 0 tines ] 30 200 31 rake
%    0 230 shift

The top quarter of the marbling is less densely threaded than the rest of the marbling. This is because, by raking downward without a compensating upward raking, the whole design has been moved downward. To recenter it pst-marble offers:

θ R shift

Shifts tank by R at θ degrees clockwise from vertical.

Uncommenting the shift line will center the nonpareil design; the value 230 was arrived at by trial and error:

    0 0 48 colors 25 concentric-rings
    90  [-150 450] 100 750 31 rake
    -90 [-150 450] 100 750 31 rake
    180 [ 25 50 0 tines ] 30 200 31 rake
    0 230 shift

The nonpareil design is common in marbling, and is the basis for more complicated designs as well. You can easily alter the appearance by changing the actions= code.
The pst-marble reference card gives brief descriptions of all the actions= commands. The next installment in this tutorial series explains how to rake curves.

Copyright © 2019 Aubrey Jaffer

---

Topological Computer Graphics
		Go Figure!

Mathematical Marblilng Software

Jürgen Gilg and Luque Manuel have collaborated to create the pst-marble package on CTAN.org which lets you create your own mathematical marblings using LaTeX.  https://ctan.org/pkg/pst-marble

http://pstricks.blogspot.com/2018/09/the-marbled-paper-with-pstricks.html
show nice examples of marblings you can create with pst-marble.


You can now create pst-marble designs online! The first tutorial (about the nonpareil pattern) is https://voluntocracy.blogspot.com/2019/02/mathematical-marbling-how-to.html

The Lamb-Oseen Vortex and Paint Marbling

Just published The Lamb-Oseen Vortex and Paint Marbling on arXiv.

The image to the left shows the decay with time of the Lamb-Oseen vortex (starting from an impulse of circulation at the center point).

The image to the right shows the same vortex, but with exponentially increasing time.  The rotational shear propagates to larger and larger orbits while the center returns to rest.  While this animation returns to its original position, it could come to rest at any angle controlled by the magnitude of the initial circulation.

More about mathematical marbling.

Vortex marbling in Jupiter's great spot

Image from NASA's Juno spacecraft 2018-04-01

Although there are structures resembling mushrooms, the sides of the caps are vortexes, not the smaller mushrooms seen in my previous post.  There appears to be a vortex street running across the bottom half of the image.

Bubbles in Marbling

Bubbles and parted paints

The St.Johns marbling technique uses stylus speeds of only a few centimeters per second. When a stylus is moved quickly through the tank fluid, air bubbles are formed. Bubbles were formed drawing a 25 mm diameter dowel faster than (V=) 20 cm/s through the tank (which also parted the floating paints) in my previous post.

While the formation of bubbles could be due to non-Newtonian fluid behavior, it is worth examining the conditions assuming a Newtonian fluid. A 25 mm diameter dowel submerged 12.5 mm will behave more like half of a 25 mm diameter sphere than a cylinder. If the kinematic viscosity (ν=0.001 m²/s) of the liquid is 1000 times that of water, then the Reynolds number is about 5, far less than the 90 needed to spawn vortexes. Re is inversely proportional to viscosity; reducing the kinematic viscosity by a factor of 10 raises Re to 50.

A half sphere of diameter d has buoyant-pressure (restoring force divided by cross-section area) of about 81 N/m². Surface tension pressure (restoring force divided by cross-section area) of water is roughly 3.7 N/m².

Drag is the force on the object moving through the tank fluid. There must be an equal and opposite net force on the liquid. Drag D for a sphere is the product of the friction coefficient C_D, frontal area (π/4*d²), and dynamic head V²*ρ/2 (for water ρ=997). That force divided by the frontal area of the object is a pressure (suction actually).

A bubble will be formed if this suction behind the moving stylus is larger than the sum of the restoring forces at the liquid surface.

For ν=1000 mm²/s (1000 times that of water) the suction behind our 25 mm diameter dowel is 88 N/m², which exceeds the restoring pressures 81 N/m² and 3.7 N/m², and bubbles can result.

The slower motions and smaller styluses that the St.Johns usually use have Reynolds numbers much smaller than 5. Thus the marblings they create don't evidence inertial effects (versus the mushroom designs of my previous post).

"Mushroom" flow from straight strokes

Kinematic viscosities below 50 mm²/s (50 times that of water) would be needed to spawn vortexes in marbling.  At 50 mm²/s viscosity, a 25 mm cylinder would need to be moved at 20 cm/s over at least 16 cm before the first vortex was shed. 

In water, a 5 mm cylinder moving at 2 cm/s would shed vortexes 3 cm apart.   A 1 mm diameter stylus moved in a straight path at 5 cm/s would not shed vortexes.

So existing evidence of Karman (shed) vortexes is only likely to be found in marbling produced on a tank filled with water.